In an interview with Katie Couric, Justice Ginsburg stated that she thought that the football players protesting by kneeling during the National Anthem were "dumb, disrespectful and stupid" and that "if they want to be stupid, there's no law that should be preventive." I have also viewed Justice Ginsburg as hero of the Constitution, liberty, justice, fairness, scholarship and progressive wisdom; however, I am lost at her comments in regards to the NFL football players' protest. I ponder if Justice Ginsburg knows what these NFL players of color are protesting. If not, let us be clear here.
The NFL is greatly composed of men of color (with mostly white owners which is reminiscent of slavery as there absolutely should be, at minimum, fifty percent Black owners of teams, which is another issue), and these men are reflecting upon the manner in which men of color, particularly African-American men, have been killed, and in some instances, outright murdered, by law enforcement. Essentially, these NFL players also could be victims of some wayward, bias, prejudiced and quick-trigger-fingered law enforcement officer. These NFL players are using their status not only to address an issue that they could be victims of, but an issue that so many like them face on a daily basis in this country. There is no way that anyone could defend each and every execution of these men of color by officers in this country. In fact, some of these very officers are facing criminal charges as a result of their conduct.
I honestly believe that African-American men, in particular, are targeted by some (not all) law enforcement officers. Some law enforcement officers' targeting anyone is more troubling for many reasons. The public has entrusted these officers to uphold the law and has given officers an immense degree of power, including the benefit of the doubt in questionable instances of officers dealing with the public. While I am profoundly disappointed with Justice Ginsburg's statements, I suspect that she, a woman of high character and moral integrity, likely does not understand precisely why these men in the NFL are protesting. If she did, I suspect that the Justice Ginsburg, who I have come to know and admire, would never call these men "dumb, disrespectful and stupid." Before I would ever utter such disappointing words, I would have simply said nothing.
I honestly believe that African-American men, in particular, are targeted by some (not all) law enforcement officers. Some law enforcement officers' targeting anyone is more troubling for many reasons. The public has entrusted these officers to uphold the law and has given officers an immense degree of power, including the benefit of the doubt in questionable instances of officers dealing with the public. While I am profoundly disappointed with Justice Ginsburg's statements, I suspect that she, a woman of high character and moral integrity, likely does not understand precisely why these men in the NFL are protesting. If she did, I suspect that the Justice Ginsburg, who I have come to know and admire, would never call these men "dumb, disrespectful and stupid." Before I would ever utter such disappointing words, I would have simply said nothing.